As a musician and music teacher I am inclined to listen. I am (according to Howard Gardner) Musically Intelligent. Which simply means I can make organizational sense of sound and tend to learn things best by listening. In this visually obsessed world, I am somewhat handicapped. This is why I was initially attracted to podcasting. There was something nifty about the concept of learning by active listening.Last summer I thought, “my students will eat this up”. They will want to make their own podcasts. They will want to listen to them all! Yeah, sure.

My initial enthusiasm waned pretty quickly once the school year got started. Responses to the concept of podcast listening and podcast creation ranged from, “what’s a podcast?” to “who cares?”. I was also feeling a time crunch to listen to all these podcasts because I made the mistake of not listening during “transition periods” during my day (see below). Then I read a blog that dissed podcasts badly (The Top 7 Reasons Online Podcasts Suck). That’s when traditional teaching returned and I unsubscribed to all those unlistened podcasts.
It’s now a year later and I am, once again, feeling the love for podcasts . This time, however, I am taking a practical approach and studying the real possibilities here. I have come to the following conclusions about podcasting:
1- Podcasts should, at least intially, be listened to alone
2- Podcasts should be highly specific and organized around subjects (for example, buddhism or fly fishing)
3- Podcats should be listened to at “transition times” during the day (because who has the time!). Such times include, commuting to work, grocery shopping, walking, jogging, waiting for the bus, etc..
I’m ready to give podcasting another go.
I agree! I have come to the same conclusion about podcasts and now use them as “on demand” professional development (mowing the lawn, commuting to work, exercising, etc.) I blogged about this on my own blog not too long ago (http://digitalmusiceducator.wordpress.com)
I find that I can glean at least 1 or 2 gems of knowledge that I follow up on- and it often leads me in new directions I hadn’t known that I want to explore!
I also have my own podcast- an Academy of Performing Arts podcast that currently only my faculty can listen to, but I find that they enjoy the way it brings us closer regarding issues in the classroom.
I agree with the first commenter, I also use Podcasts as a personal development tool. I listen while driving, sitting on the bus, while in the car etc. I no longer feel as if that time is just wasted away.
I attend McNally Smith School of Music in St. Paul Minnesota and in one of my classes we are working towards creating our own. It’s become pretty popular among the student population.